Thread:Deathstalker666/@comment-1915529-20140221183807/@comment-1915529-20140514061409

In Jedi you see Luke and Han's friendship reach new levels as they become the best of friends, something that happened over the course of all three films. Plus you have Leia and Han reunited following the devastating events on Bespin.

Replacing Sebastian with Hayden makes no sense. It feels like something someone has done to add to the CGI budget to make a few extra quid. If they wanted to make it make sense then they would have replaced old ben's ghost with McGregor. I'm surprised they never replaced all scenes with the Yoda puppet with a CGI freak show. But then that would be even worse than Vader saying No.

Palpatine didn't hear Vader because he didn't actually say no at the time. You see when filming, Vader would stand around on set and say nothing. He voice comes from someone else whose lines are added in editing. This normally does not matter because Palpatine being a Sith Lord gives him the power to hear what Vader would say in editing so that is why he is able to communicate with him. However the 'No' lines were added many decades later and not even a Sith Lord can hear lines in editing that far into the future.

Yoda is a great example of how using CGI instead of a puppet actually make it look worse. So it's good the Taunton looks like it.